KRLD Radio

The Business of Health Care Report
Too Much Regulation? - February 2004


Click to listen to this taped broadcast.

Doug Hawthorne, President and CEO of Texas Health Resources I'm Doug Hawthorne, President and CEO of Texas Health Resources, with "The Business of Health Care Report" on News Radio 1080 KRLD.

Today, we will examine government regulation of health care and how it impacts consumers.

Most health care providers understand that regulation is necessary to assure basic protections for patients, prevent fraud and promote access to care. But those who give care – hospitals, physicians, nurses and others – are increasingly concerned that health care regulation is out of control and has lost a sense of fairness and common sense.

Every time a nurse, physician or other health care worker cares for a patient, a host of regulations and statutes govern their actions, especially if the patient is a Medicare or Medicaid recipient. The rules extend far beyond providing quality care … sometimes too far. The Mayo Foundation estimates that caregivers are subject to 132,390 pages of rules that govern Medicare and Medicaid. In the hospital emergency department, every hour dedicated to patient care generates an hour of paperwork, says a PricewaterhouseCoopers study conducted on behalf of the American Hospital Association.

And this is only federal regulation. Hospitals also are regulated by local and state agencies, as well as other private accrediting organizations.

The issue is not whether to regulate but how. A necessary first step is to create a more reasonable approach to developing and issuing future regulations. Equally critical is the need to provide relief from the most burdensome, inefficient or ineffective regulations that take away from critical time spent with patients. Change in the way hospitals are regulated also should be driven by broader health care policy decisions, such as the way in which health care coverage and access are financed.

It is important for our elected officials at the federal, state and local levels to examine regulations that work, those that don’t and to help shape a realistic role for regulation in health care – with more patient time and less paperwork hassles.

While the circumstances for the growing number of uninsured Americans are varied, the end result is simple. Until something changes, other efforts to improve health care will be done with one arm tied behind our backs.

For Texas Health Resources and its family of hospitals - Harris Methodist Hospitals, Presbyterian Healthcare System and Arlington Memorial Hospital - I'm CEO Doug Hawthorne with "The Business of Health Care Report" on NewsRadio 1080 KRLD.

Doug Hawthorne

Archives | Close Window

© 2004 Texas Health Resources
All Rights Reserved

Sources: U.S. Bureau of the Census, Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2002, issued September 2003

Close Window